Listings in Lyndonville, NY

Wow! Absolutely gorgeous cottage and pole barn in mint condition on over a half acre. This property has so much to offer along with the fabulous views. Relax and enjoy the sunsets and sunrises from the new stamped concrete covered patio, or from the waterfront deck. Full concrete and rock break wall. Cottage was gutted and rebuilt with 2 additions from 2005+. Metal roof is 4 yrs old. Greet your guests in the spacious great room with all new flooring, fresh paint, tilt-in windows and Mitsubishi split system for heat and a/c. 5 year old 36' x 64' Pole barn built by TNT Builders of Newfane. Barn features a full concrete floor, 16' walls, 14' doors with auto lifts, electric, water, and a separate septic system with roughed in plumbing ready to go! So much potential! There is also a 12 x 28 shed and a great neighborhood! $425,000 Pending

11481 Robinson Lane 4 Yates, New York

2 Beds 1 Baths 960 SqFt 0.573 Acres

LAKE ONTARIO!!!Discover a rare opportunity to own your very own point on Lake Ontario, where breathtaking views and peaceful living come together in perfect harmony. This 3-bedroom, 1-bath colonial, built new in 2000, sits on two parcels of land that have been combined with over 75 feet of lake frontage on LAKE ONTARIO and nearly 200 feet along Perch Creek...an unmatched setting for year-round living or a tranquil getaway. At the heart of the home is a soaring great room with cathedral ceilings, skylights, ceiling fans, and a dramatic wall of windows framing the lake. The open kitchen features warm cabinetry, a breakfast bar, and a walkout to the expansive wraparound deck, ideal for entertaining or enjoying endless sunsets. The first-floor primary bedroom offers comfort and convenience, while the upstairs loft and two generous bedrooms provide space for family, guests, or even a home office. The natural wood staircase, trim, and charming window details add warmth throughout. Outdoors, mature trees create privacy and shade while still allowing abundant sunlight to fill the home. From the deck, take in panoramic views of Lake Ontario and Perch Creek, or explore shallow waters perfect for kayaking, fishing, and wading. With a simple permit, you could even add a dock for boating or summer fun. Additional highlights include a brand-new roof (2025) 2 NEW skylights, a new septic system (2018), and a tankless hot water system (2021) for energy-efficient comfort. A second parcel offers garage/storage space for up to 3 cars, workshop potential, or extra room for lake toys. Whether you seek a full-time waterfront lifestyle or a serene vacation retreat, this property delivers a setting that calms the body, mind, and spirit every day. Imagine morning coffee overlooking the water, evenings by the fire with sunset views, and a lifestyle defined by the sound of waves and the beauty of nature. Don’t miss your chance to own this extraordinary property on Lake Ontario. Showings start Sept 1, 2025 Offers due Sept 16, 2025 at 1:00PM $375,000 Pending

12613 Green Acres Drive Carlton, New York

3 Beds 1 Baths 1,600 SqFt 0.56 Acres

Set on a picturesque 1.7-acre corner lot, this fully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath residence in Lyndonville masterfully blends timeless character with sophisticated updates. From the moment you step inside, you're greeted by a light-filled, flowing layout where custom live edge wood accents and curated finishes create a sense of artisan craftsmanship and warmth. The first-floor primary suite offers a spa-like escape, featuring a Jacuzzi tub for ultimate relaxation. A first-floor full bath and laundry room add ease and function without compromising style. Outdoors, the property continues to impress with a 30x30 detached garage equipped with a lift—perfect for the automotive enthusiast or craftsman—and a 2-story outbuilding bursting with potential for a studio, workshop, or expansive storage. Whether you're entertaining guests or enjoying a quiet morning on your land, this home offers the rare combination of privacy, style, and convenience—just minutes from the shores of Lake Ontario. A truly move-in-ready sanctuary where every detail has been elevated. Square Footage Measured via Cuba Casa $314,900 Active

10655 Millers Road Yates, New York

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,855 SqFt 1.7 Acres

This one is a must see! Complete renovation to the entire home. The owners have spared nothing! Brand new roof, windows, doors, kitchen, bathrooms, flooring, furnace, HWT, new electrical riser, new 200amp electrical panel. This home has been completely overhauled and renovated for its new owners. Don't miss out on this gorgeous 2,760sqft home with one car attached garage and barn for extra storage or your toys! Delayed negotiations until Friday August 15th at 12:00PM $279,900 Pending

1190 Marshall Road Yates, New York

4 Beds 3 Baths 2,760 SqFt 5.4 Acres

Welcome to this beautiful well maintained 3 season cottage on beautiful lake Ontario. Sit out on your back patio or enclosed sun room drinking your coffee in the mornng and watching the prettiest sunsets at night overlooking the lake! $275,000 Pending

11477 Robinson Lane 4 Yates, New York

2 Beds 1 Baths 836 SqFt 0.355 Acres

Welcome to your perfect year-round getaway on the lake! This beautifully maintained home offers the best of lakeside living with modern updates and breathtaking views. Enjoy a spacious updated kitchen (2018), new windows (2022) with transferable warranty, a new roof (2023), and a new water tank (2021). Take in stunning sunsets from the front or back deck, or gather around the patio firepit by the water for unforgettable evenings. Inside, the home boasts a large dining area overlooking the lake, extra space in the kitchen perfect for a coffee bar or potential future laundry room, a generous living room perfect for entertaining, plus bedrooms on both the first and second floor. The large first-floor full bath adds convenience and comfort. You’ll be just a short distance from attractions like Lakeside Beach State Park, Hamlin Beach State Park, and the charming town of Olcott, filled with shops, restaurants, and entertainment. Whether you’re looking for a weekend escape or a year-round residence, this lake house offers it all—updates, space, and the unbeatable beauty of Lake Ontario right outside your door. Septic cleaned July 2025. $230,000 Active

10347 Chaffee Lane Yates, New York

2 Beds 1 Baths 1,272 SqFt 0.258 Acres

Come and experience this fine Colonial style house with it's distinguishing wrap around porch! Each room has it's own individual character and charm! The formal dining room really stands out with it's own chandelier! There is a natural flow from room to room as you navigate through the first floor as you'll see in the photos! The bedrooms are all nice size upstairs and the attic could be utilized for additional living space. The garage should comfortably fit 2 cars and then some! Call for easy showings! Delayed Negotiations commence Monday, August 18th at 5:00pm. $224,900 Pending

150 Maple Avenue Yates, New York

4 Beds 2 Baths 2,352 SqFt 0.251 Acres

Looking to invest-this could be the place. 3 units, current rent totals $2,825, modest rents for the market but excellent tenants. New leach bed as designed by engineer and approved by town provides peace of mind in the future. Drainage was added on east side to prevent water seepage to the home. Ample parking and two car garage. Separate utilities to each unit. $199,900 Active

1372 N Lyndonville Road Yates, New York

5 Beds 4 Baths 3,168 SqFt 0.379 Acres

Hard to find Lake Ontario cottage with 100' of lake frontage and public water. The Cottage has newer Metal roof and Vinyl siding. Plenty of room for a large family boasting 4 bedrooms and a ton of land to expand! New Rock wall was installed after the flood years. Great property! $199,900 Active

10773 Smythe Lane 39 Yates, New York

4 Beds 1 Baths 1,296 SqFt 0.689 Acres

3 Bedroom 2 bath manufactured home on land in Mint condition! The home is only 10 years old but Mr. and Mrs. fussy live here and have made soo many improvements! Kitchen cabinets, quartz counters, backsplash and floor is less than 1 year old. Both Baths are all remodeled. 2 windows added, new trim and moldings, all new vinyl plank flooring except the brand new carpeting being installed in 2 bedrooms on Oct. 13. Amish Metal roof is 6 years old. There is a large shed plus a workshop that is fully insulated and heated. Also outside you will find a rear deck, a hot tub building with hot tub included and a covered patio for watching the games or just relaxing with a good book. Home has propane heat with central air, a large corner lot with raised gardens and lilac bushes, blacktop driveway. This is a must see! $199,000 Pending

1997 Greenman Road Yates, New York

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,120 SqFt 0.41 Acres

BACK ON THE MARKET! Welcome to 12742 Roustabout Terrace in the heart of Carlton! This 3-bedroom, 1-bath home offers 960 sq ft of thoughtfully designed space. Step inside to enjoy a cozy living room with a wood-burning stove and a freshly renovated upstairs. Recent updates include a newer furnace and AC (2019), vinyl siding (2019), and a metal roof with gutters (2018) for peace of mind. Set on a double lot with 1.2 acres, the property boasts lake views, deeded lake access, and a private covered patio perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Located near Lake Ontario, this home is ideal for fishing, outdoor enjoyment, and quiet living. Don’t miss your chance to make this beautiful property your next home — schedule a showing today! **Seller will winterize the property the week of October 31st unless told otherwise. $180,000 Pending

12742 Roustabout Terrace Carlton, New York

3 Beds 1 Baths 960 SqFt 1.2 Acres

Charming 1,566 sq ft Cape Cod featuring 4 bedrooms and a garage. Set on over half an acre surrounded by peaceful cornfields, this home offers privacy and scenic views. The fully fenced yard includes an Amish-made shed for additional storage, a maintenance-free deck perfect for relaxing or entertaining, and a front-row seat to annual fireworks displays. Inside, the home has been newly remodeled throughout, featuring beautifully stained wood accents, new lighting fixtures, a newly remodeled kitchen and bathroom, and an upgraded 200-amp service. The drylocked, clean basement offers excellent storage or hobby space, and a durable metal roof adds long-lasting protection and peace of mind. $179,900 Pending

208 West Avenue Yates, New York

4 Beds 1 Baths 1,566 SqFt 0.54 Acres

whipple realty

(585) 765-2000

5 South Main Street
Lyndonville, NY 14098

email us

“Jeanne, you were a pleasure to work with. It meant a lot to us to have someone so honest &: trustworthy with your knowledge base and experience on our side.”

Lisa R.

“Overall your realty company is outstanding! Most notable is your knowledge of the area … and especially your honesty throughout the process.”

Jon B.